The curiously common curse keeping this mansion in disrepair

At 1000 Ocean Avenue in Brooklyn sits a historic landmark locals call “the scary house.” It’s for sale for $2.3 million—and according to Compass listing agent Laura Rozos, there’s a reason it’s still on the market.

Q: What’s the story of this house? “It was built in 1899 by architect George Palliser. Over the years, various families have tried to fix it up but never progressed—a classic story. One couple was there for 15 years and lived in one bedroom with a makeshift kitchen. The last owner had it for three years but didn’t anticipate what it would take to navigate the Landmarks Preservation Commission. That’s why he’s selling.”

Q: How bad is the home’s condition? “It’s known as the ‘scary house.’ It’s like a horror movie in there. There’s a room filled with taxidermy. A flying goose hangs from a chandelier. Squatters jump the fence to get in. The renovation would cost a minimum of $2 million. Based on comparable properties in the area, I think the after-repair value would be over $6 million.”

Q: Have you received any offers? “We have received offers, but nothing accepted. This house needs somebody who has a passion for restoration and experience navigating landmarks.”

Q: What do you hope happens to this house? “This house has generated such a response from the community. I’ve lived two blocks from this house for 26 years. We are all distressed that it’s deteriorating. It’s such a shame. Everybody is rooting for this house. Everybody wants it revived and restored.”